An
internationally recognized expert on sustainable tourism, Costas Christ
serves as the Judging Chairman of the
World Travel and Tourism Council -
Tourism for Tomorrow Awards. He is a contributing editor and columnist for
National Geographic Adventure magazine and also the Chairman of the
Adventures in Travel Expo Conferences in North America. He supports Big
Five Tours and Expeditions as their “Ambassador at Large” for their Spirit
of Big Five travel philanthropy program that supports the protection of
cultural and natural heritage in tourism destinations around the world.
His own travels and work have taken him to more than 100 countries across
six continents including expeditions to some of the world’s most remote
wilderness areas and archaeological sites.
He is a founding member and former Chairman of the
Board of The International Ecotourism Society and served as Senior
Director for Ecotourism at Conservation International in Washington DC,
where he supervised ecotourism projects in 18 countries.
In addition to his monthly column in National
Geographic Adventure, Costas' articles and essays on travel and tourism
have appeared in numerous publications, including the International Herald
Tribune, New York Times, and Sunday Times of London. He is the lead author
of Tourism and Biodiversity: Mapping Tourism Global Footprint and a
contributing author in Wilderness: Earth's Last Wild Places and has
appeared many times on television and radio, including CNN, BBC, National
Public Radio, Voice of America, CBS, ABC, and PBS.
(The Interview follows:)
ECOCLUB.com:
You are a true Ecotourism pioneer with a 360 degree knowledge of
Ecotourism worldwide, as a founding Member of TIES, a senior officer in
many ecotourism-related organisations, an accomplished ecotour guide in
Africa and Central America, a travel journalist for major publications,
with a career in public and private sectors. So what made such an able and
ambitious person believe in the potential of Ecotourism and how has it
lived up to your expectations? What would be the "Costas Christ"
definition of Ecotourism?
Costas Christ: In 1990, I sat around a table at an old farmhouse
outside of Washington DC with a handful of people from different countries
who shared the same vision and we spent two days trying to come up with
what would become the first definition of ecotourism - "Responsible travel
to natural areas that protects nature and sustains the wellbeing of local
peoples." It was the first Board of Director's meeting of The
International Ecotourism Society and that definition we came up with is
still the guiding definition for ecotourism all around the world. For me,
that is how I continue to define ecotourism to this day. Of course, there
are many other aspects that pertain to ecotourism, but in that definition
you will find the two pillars upon which ecotourism stands - protecting
nature and bringing benefits to local people - socially, culturally and
economically. For me, the ideas for ecotourism began back in 1978 when I
was living and working in Africa. I had originally gone to Kenya to
participate in a wildlife research project in the remote Samburu Game
Reserve. During my time there, I found myself in the middle of a growing
conflict between local people, struggling to meet basic needs around the
park and the park rangers who were tasked with protecting the wildlife. In
the middle of this drama of conflict between local people and park
managers over access to natural resources - grazing land, wood, water -
was a thriving tourism safari industry generating millions of dollars for
business owners in far away capital cities like Nairobi and London. Yet
the local people who lived closest to what the tourists were coming to see
were struggling to survive, facing poverty, while every day park rangers
had to contend with poor equipment and little funds available to monitor
and protect the wildlife that was at the center of the conflict.
It
occurred to me sitting around a camp fire each night, and after learning
the local language and getting to know the concerns of the local villagers
first hand, that conservation of rare and endangered wildlife and
protection of natural habitat would never succeed unless the people who
lived closest to those places we want to protect, become partners and
allies in the process. In the middle of all this was tourism generating
huge profits. I thought that tourism - properly planned and managed -
could be the economic engine to address poverty and generate the funding
needed to effectively manage and protect wilderness areas. The local
people would become partners and allies when they had a direct stake in
the management and economic benefits of tourism and when protected areas
got a bigger piece of the tourism economic pie. In the case of tourism
itself, it seemed to me that the very foundation for business success in
the long term was to protect the natural and cultural heritage of our
planet. I started calling this idea "conservation sociology" in the 1970s.
In the 1980's, I was referring to it as environmental tourism and by 1990,
it had morphed into ecotourism. During this same time period, other people
in Africa and elsewhere in the world were having similar ideas and
eventually we would connect with each other and put in motion a global
ecotourism movement. I still believe in it as passionately today as I did
in the shadows of Mount Kenya when these thoughts first entered my mind 29
years ago. Along the way, there have been many challenges but we have
learned from failures and built upon the successes.
I think
it is accurate to say today that ecotourism was the catalyst for
transforming the way we travel. There are now hundreds of successful
ecotourism projects and businesses around the world. Sustainable tourism,
agro-tourism, geotourism, green travel - all of these different offshoots
of responsible travel practices grew out of the early days of ecotourism.
ECOCLUB.com:
Is there a real need for Ecotourism certification? Is it feasible?
Costas Christ: I think that certification will eventually come
whether we think it should or not. Travellers continue to ask for an
easier way for well-meaning tourists who want to take a nature or
adventure trip to have some kind of label or certification that they can
rely on to know what companies are doing the real work to make tourism an
opportunity for our planet and not a threat to it.
We do not
yet have a globally accepted standard for ecotourism certification nor an
easy way to fund such a global certification scheme but Eco-Australia's
certification program, Rainforest Alliance's "Smart Voyager" certification
and the CST program in Costa Rica are examples of the evolution of working
certification programs that seem to be having a good impact.
ECOCLUB.com:
In relation to your experience in Africa, does tourism make a real
difference? Can it really bring peace and prosperity or are these
prerequisites? Do luxury safaris and exclusive lodges adequately benefit
local communities overall, apart from a handful of community-owned luxury
lodges? Is luxury and exclusivity morally acceptable in this continent, or
should tourists rather patronise more modest outfits?
Costas Christ: Africa should cast its net wide and have all forms of
tourism from low cost safaris to high end luxury. Of course, what type of
tourism you have varies from destination to destination, but certainly
there are excellent luxury camps like Campi Ya Kanzi in Kenya or Phinda
Private Reserve in South Africa that have had major positive impacts on
the lives of local people and protection of nature. Tourism done well
according to the principles of sustainability, can make a significant
contribution to the economic well being of rural peoples and the
protection of wildlife in Africa. And a prerequisite for tourism's
economic and social benefits is peace and stability. At the same time,
tourism can also lead to more peace and stability between countries. The
East African countries of Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda are continuing to
look at how they can once again (post cold-war era) create a working East
African Community of nations to promote economic and political cooperation
through the movement of tourists across their borders. In Mozambique, the
Peace Park that straddles Mozambique and South Africa came together as a
way to facilitate tourism economic development in the region as well as
promote conservation and peace.
So
tourism can play an important role in building bridges of cooperation and
understanding between the governments and peoples of different countries.
Also, when it comes to international tourists, having more Americans and
Europeans travelling to Africa in a responsible way allows them to get to
know Africans first hand. It helps to dispel the myths and stereotypes
about Africa and Africans and allows Westerners an opportunity to
understand that Africa is not just a place of tragedy but one of hope,
incredible natural history and about the strength and dignity of her
peoples.
ECOCLUB.com:
As an ecotour operator and activist do you voice your concerns about human
rights and social injustices or do you prefer to "leave only footprints"
as the mantra goes?
Costas Christ: My entire involvement with ecotourism from the very
beginning has been about addressing fundamental human needs - the right to
education, health care, clean water, food, and social justice - just as
much as it has been about protecting the environment and saving wildlife.
In the
late 1980's, I was declared persona non grata and ordered out of
Kenya by the Moi regime because of my stinging political criticisms
published in the New York Times and International Herald Tribune about the
government's human rights abuses, rampant corruption and escalating
wildlife poaching in and around national parks. A close friend of mine -
an old Kenya park ranger who was like a mentor to me - was killed by
poachers in 1989 who drove on the main road right into Meru National Park
in day light and drove out with no problem whatsoever. To me that is as
much a human rights abuse as it is a crisis for protecting wildlife. Kenya
is much better off today than it was then with leaders like Nobel Peace
Prize winner, Wangari Mathai, serving in the government which is why it
has also had a resurgence in tourism in recent years. But economic and
social justice along with protecting nature are core values that should be
found in all ecotourism practices.
ECOCLUB.com:
Recently when you were presenting the prestigious 2007 Tourism for
Tomorrow Awards, in Portugal, you stated: "the winners represent a major
turning point in the global tourism industry. Gone are the days when there
were only a handful of ecolodges or a few small tour operators who were
doing sustainable tourism successfully. Today's best practice models also
represent major tourism destinations and global tourism companies that are
helping to protect cultural and natural heritage and support the well
being of local peoples." So, are global tourism giants really doing
enough? Some believe that they only offer a pittance as a share of profits
to social & environmental projects and that the rest is motivated by CSR
considerations for their annual reports. Is there a real cause for
celebration?
Costas Christ: Fifteen years ago, people said that ecotourism would
never work because the companies would never really offer more than lip
service to the principles of protecting nature and sustaining the well
being of local people. They were right in the sense that some companies
did nothing more than a pittance, as you say, to the real principles of
ecotourism. But many more companies went much further and the result today
is that ecotourism is no longer an experiment. It is a reality with
successful ecotourism companies operating across the world and making a
positive difference in the lives of local people and protecting nature.
Around
the year 2000, seeing considerable success with ecotourism, I became
worried that most of that success was confined to what I would call "mom
and pop" small businesses. I began to think that we might look back 20
years from now at the legacy of ecotourism and see that we were just able
to change 5 percent or less of the global tourism industry - not enough to
make tourism a real opportunity for safeguarding cultural and natural
heritage around the planet and addressing poverty alleviation. So I
shifted tactics and began to focus my attention on the
mainstream tourism industry, embracing sustainable tourism which
basically takes the principles first associated with ecotourism and
applies them to urban hotels as well as large tourism resorts, airlines,
cruise ships, etc. In other words, bringing the principles of
environmentally-friendly operations, giving back to support cultural
heritage preservation and contributing to nature protection right into the
heart of the entire global tourism industry. It is a huge challenge but I
am convinced that the issue before us is not "does sustainable tourism
work" but rather just how far can we take sustainable tourism to transform
global tourism into a catalyst for helping to protect our planet, address
climate change and make peoples lives better. We are off to an encouraging
start as more larger companies adopt these practices. In many respects,
given the staggering growth rate of the travel and tourism industry,
nothing less than the future of our planet is at stake. There is so much
to gain if we get it right with sustainable tourism and so much to lose if
we do not.
ECOCLUB.com:
And talking about Awards, from your experience, how satisfied are you
about the relevance of Awards for encouraging real change in Tourism? Who
is entitled to vote in these Awards - and what about conflict of
interests? (panel member one year, award winner the other).
Costas Christ: I think that well conceived sustainable tourism award
programs with a transparent methodology and real teeth in verification of
winners claims, are very important for recognizing the best practices that
are out there as models for others to see and learn from as well as for
giving credit to the companies that have worked hard to make sustainable
tourism a reality.
In the
case of WTTC's Tourism for Tomorrow Awards, of which I have been the
Chairman of Judges for the last 3 years, it has been extremely important
for these Awards to set the standard for the industry recognition of best
practices. We have over a dozen international judges from all over the
world representing different areas of expertise - government, private
sector, non-profit, academic, etc - along with other experts who make
on site inspection visits of all Award finalists to make sure that
what they are saying they are doing in sustainable practices is really
being done on the ground. I know of no other global tourism award program
that does on site inspection visits and evaluation reports in addition to
collecting voluntary information presented by the companies in their Award
applications. So it is a very rigorous process and methodology in
selecting finalists and winners. While we do invite some former winners to
become judges (given their demonstrated expertise in sustainable
practices) we have never had nor would we permit someone to serve as a
judge one year and then apply for the Award the next as you mentioned.
Each year we continue to look for ways that we can improve the Tourism for
Tomorrow Awards and in the process, the award winners and finalists serve
as models showing that sustainable tourism "can be done". This is a
particularly important message for the big companies out there and they
are starting to listen more as evidenced by this year's winners.
ECOCLUB.com:
Do you feel that Tourism progresses rapidly enough, in terms of working
conditions and environmental impact? (If not, what in your view needs to
be done to speed up social & environmental progress in Tourism?)
Costas Christ: I wish it was proceeding more rapidly in terms of
better working conditions and environmental impacts but we cannot give up
in our efforts to make that happen. Since so much of tourism depends on
the integrity of cultural and natural heritage attractions in destinations
around the world along with an excellent tourism product, ultimately
sustainable tourism is as much about good business planning as it is about
altruism. We cannot and should not give up in our ongoing work with the
public and private sectors to make tourism the opportunity it can be for
our planet and its peoples - particularly in developing nations that may
be rich in natural habitat and cultural diversity but poor in economic
resources. We need to remain steadfast and learn from our mistakes to help
tourism reach its highest potential to make a better contribution to the
world. This has been my guiding philosophy for nearly 30 years now in
trying to transform this industry in positive ways.
ECOCLUB.com:
Both of your parents are from Greece, you grew up in the States while you
have travelled and worked all around the world. This self-globalisation is
increasingly expected from world leaders, especially in the Tourism
sector. You have kept in touch with your roots, and groundroots through
your work, however, from your experience, do most of your high-flying
peers have time to relate to local / national sensitivities, prejudices,
worries? Is that a problem when devising international tourism policy?
Costas Christ: About ten years ago, I told a journalist that one of my
fears was that ecotourism would do more for the jet set conference
industry than it would for local people and the environment. While I do
not think that has happened, I do feel that it is incumbent on anyone who
truly wants to be involved with these issues in constructive ways to keep
themselves with one foot fully grounded into the lives and aspirations of
local people and the natural environment that we are all ultimately
connected to. The other foot needs to be in the world of policy makers and
private sector CEO's etc that are making big decisions to affect the lives
and environment for people the world over. I left Washington DC and moved
to a farm in Maine six years ago so I could live closer to the family
farmers and small communities in North America that are trying to survive
in the face of globalization. In that sense, it is kind of a reverse of
the slogan " Think Global, Act Local." In my case, it is more, "Think
Local, Act Global".
ECOCLUB.com:
You have written numerous articles for some of the leading English
language newspapers and television channels, so you know both sides of
Ecotourism media coverage. How fair are the media in their coverage of
Ecotourism? Recently a major news agency invited to Oslo for the GEC could
only cynically report that 'Ecotourism is equally harmful' ignoring all
that was discussed and presented. Why do media always give the benefit of
the doubt to other forms of tourism, such as Responsible, Ethical and so
on, but are so eager to bash Ecotourism? Are they jealous or a victim of
orchestrated misinformation?
Costas Christ: Some media in their pursuit for "news" like to build
things up and then bash it down. We saw this happen with ecotourism. Media
has jumped on the bandwagon of reporting on efforts to save the
environment and then on the bandwagon, in their minds, of why those
efforts are failing or false, or whatever. I cannot tell you how many
reporters I know who are asked to write about ecotourism and still think
it means a bird watching trip, missing the underlying principles that can
change a nature vacation into ecotourism. Just going on safari does
not mean ecotourism. Yet many reporters miss that important fact. When I
saw the article you mentioned that came out of the recent Global
Ecotourism Conference in Olso state that ecotourism experts now say
ecotourism is damaging the world, I thought to myself how misinformed that
was and how misleading it is to the general public. The truth is that if
travel were to stop today from going to the far flung corners of our
planet to see nature we would experience an environmental nightmare. With
no economic incentive to protect the Serengeti through tourism, the vast
plains that hold the last great land migration of wild animals on our
planet will become grazing land for domestic cattle. The Pantanal in
Brazil, largely protected because of its ecotourism potential would be
lost to other development and cattle ranches. South East Asia's coral
reefs and marine national parks would have little incentive for protection
through the economic benefits of marine tourism. We would see species
vanish like the Scarlet Macaw in Belize if there was no economic reason
through ecotourism to protect them for visitors willing to pay money to
see and photograph them. The list goes on. Before anyone says that we need
to stop travelling to save the earth, they should think very carefully
about what that would do to protected areas around the planet and to the
peoples whose economic livelihood is from tourism in places like El Nido
in the Philippines, where tourism income can mean the difference between
poverty and feeding your family. The issue is not to limit or stop
travelling as a way to deal with global warming, etc. Travel is part of
our very human nature and has been with us for a long time. The very
definition of a human being in ancient Tibetan - the word groba -
means one who goes on migrations. Rather, in modern times, we need to work
on how travel can be more sustainable. That is the goal.
ECOCLUB.com:
You have already accomplished many things for Ecotourism. What next?
Costas Christ: My efforts are focused on greening the mainstream
tourism industry now. How we bring the principles of sustainability into
the full spectrum of travel and tourism worldwide. My goal is nothing less
than to transform global tourism into a force for helping to save our
planet. Together, I honestly believe we can make this happen. There
has been tremendous progress in recent years and truly, I never imagined
we would even be this far along today in terms of the many examples of
sustainable tourism success that are out there now. But we still have a
way to go to get to our destination. As the great Greek writer and
philosopher, Nikos Kazantzakis said, "It is by aligning ourselves with
the cause of our times that our life bears fruit". Protecting nature
and supporting the well being of local people around the world is a worthy
cause. It is the road I have chosen to travel.
ECOCLUB.com:
Thank you very much!
Find the
complete list of ECOCLUB Interviews here